A quick note to say that Jo my editor has come back to me on Our Child of Two Worlds, she is very happy, and we are through to copyedits.
Publication pencilled in for November although slipping to January 2022 is not beyond the bounds of possibility. I know, I’m impatient too. The pandemic has thrown timetables awry.
Copyediting works at the level of scene, paragraph and sentence, not least as the draft has piled on the pounds as I worked on it. I’m looking forward to this, not least because it holds no fears – it is getting the book into shape, not arguing about what type of book it is and what exactly to focus.
I know so much more about writing a sequel now!
Editing is important feedback, and certainly made Our Child of the Stars a clearer, better paced, and more focused book. You don’t always agree with the editor’s edicts – so what do you do?
It reminds me of a quote which summed up the issue with feedback. Is feedback right, and what do you do about it?
There is good advice out there, but a writer must walk a knife’s edge. They must be humble and open minded enough to accept criticism and be willing to change. Yet, they must be confident enough in their own style to ignore bad advice. The problem is telling the two types of advice apart.
(Quote from Petewood – literally some random guy on the same writing bulletin board I use)
I think it goes broader than style but to intent. And it is not necessarily that advice / feedback is bad.
One of the crucial things I learned from writing groups is the necessity to accept feedback that you don’t like may be right – but also the possibility that some advice offered firmly may not be right for you, or this story. Some people hand down advice like they have tablets of stone on Mount Sinai.
That’s why in addition to tenancy, ability, and luck, I would always say ‘learn how to take feedback as dispassionately as you can, and know what to do with it’. You will also get contradictory feedback.
Jo and I agree what this book is trying to be. Therefore, pointed in the same direction, I can judge her notes as trying to get us down the road. Maybe her concerns will be met her way, or another way I will find, or maybe but not often, it will be a no.
Bring it on.